Southern Tier Caramel Pumking 4Pk

Southern Tier Caramel Pumking 4Pk is a caramel-infused imperial pumpkin ale from Southern Tier Brewing Company, bottled at 8.6% ABV. Built on the foundation of the brewery’s iconic Pumking recipe, this variant amplifies the sweetness with a bold caramel dimension layered over the signature pumpkin spice character, earning a 3.8 rating across nearly 24,000 reviews on Untappd.
Quick Facts: ABV: 8.6%  |  Origin: Lakewood, New York  |  Style: Imperial Pumpkin Ale  |  Brewery: Southern Tier Brewing Company
Production & Heritage
Southern Tier Brewing Company operates out of Lakewood in Chautauqua County, western New York. The brewery’s original Pumking established itself as one of the most recognized pumpkin ales in the American craft beer landscape, and Caramel Pumking builds on that reputation with an adjusted malt bill featuring 2-row pale malt, caramel malt, and pureed pumpkin. Compared to the original Pumking, this variant uses a darker malt selection and carries a higher IBU count, providing a subtle counterbalance to the added caramel sweetness.
Tasting Notes
Aroma: Big, sweet pumpkin spice leads immediately, followed by a distinct caramel note that separates it from the original Pumking. Underneath, warm cinnamon and a suggestion of vanilla round out the nose.
Taste: Caramel hits first, coating the palate with smooth, luscious sweetness. As it recedes, pumpkin takes center stage alongside cinnamon, nutmeg, and pie crust flavors. A slight bitter, dry edge across the roof of the mouth provides balance against the sweetness and prevents the ale from becoming cloying.
Finish: Medium-long with lingering pumpkin spice and residual caramel sweetness. The malt backbone adds a gentle toasty quality that trails off cleanly.
How to Drink Caramel Pumking
Pour into a tulip glass or snifter at 45–50°F to let the caramel aromatics fully develop; this is an ale meant to be savored slowly given its 8.6% ABV. A Pumpkin Shandy — mixing half Caramel Pumking with ginger beer — tempers the sweetness with spicy effervescence. A Black Velvet variation using Caramel Pumking floated over a dry stout creates a rich, layered contrast of roast and spice. For a dessert-style serve, try a Caramel Pumking Float poured over vanilla bean ice cream, where the ale’s carbonation and bitterness cut through the dairy richness.
Best For
Autumn tastings and harvest-themed dinner parties
Sharing with craft beer enthusiasts who appreciate bold seasonal releases
Pairing alongside Thanksgiving dessert courses
Side-by-side comparison flights with the original Pumking
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Caramel Pumking taste like? Caramel Pumking leads with a pronounced caramel sweetness that gives way to warm pumpkin, cinnamon, nutmeg, and pie crust flavors. A subtle bitter edge and toasty malt backbone keep the sweetness in check.
How does Caramel Pumking compare to the original Pumking? The original Pumking delivers pumpkin spice and vanilla without the added caramel layer, resulting in a slightly drier profile. Caramel Pumking uses a darker malt selection and higher IBU to offset its greater sweetness, making it a richer, more dessert-forward expression.
Is Caramel Pumking good for sipping? At 8.6% ABV with a complex spice and caramel profile, Caramel Pumking drinks best when sipped slowly from a tulip glass, where its aromatics and malt complexity can fully unfold.
Where is Caramel Pumking made? Caramel Pumking is brewed by Southern Tier Brewing Company in Lakewood, New York, located in Chautauqua County in the western part of the state.
What foods pair well with Caramel Pumking? Pumpkin pie and pecan tarts mirror the ale’s spice and caramel notes. Sharp aged cheddar provides a savory counterpoint to the sweetness. Roasted turkey or glazed ham complement the warm spice profile, while bread pudding with caramel sauce amplifies the dessert character.
What sizes does Caramel Pumking come in? Caramel Pumking is commonly available in a 4-pack format, which is the standard retail packaging for this seasonal release.
Is Caramel Pumking worth the price? Caramel Pumking positions as a seasonal, limited-availability imperial ale within the craft beer segment, and its 8.6% ABV and layered complexity place it in line with other premium pumpkin ales in terms of value.
Why Caramel Pumking?
Southern Tier’s original Pumking already set a high bar among imperial pumpkin ales, and the Caramel variant justifies its existence by meaningfully altering the experience rather than simply adding a marketing twist. The adjusted malt bill — darker grains and a higher IBU — demonstrates genuine recipe development, not just flavoring dropped into an existing beer. With nearly 24,000 Untappd ratings holding at 3.8, it has proven its appeal across a broad cross-section of craft beer drinkers. For anyone who finds the original Pumking already impressive and wants a richer, more dessert-leaning take on the same foundation, this is the logical next pour.