Smooth Ambler Old Scout American Whiskey 750ML

Smooth Ambler Old Scout American Whiskey 750ML is a 99-proof (49.5% ABV) blended American whiskey from West Virginia’s Greenbrier County in a 750ml bottle. This expression earned 91 points at the 2018 Ultimate Spirits Challenge and has collected Gold and Grand Gold medals at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition — recognition that reflects a genuinely unusual production approach involving rejuvenated bourbon casks.
Quick Facts: ABV: 49.5% (99 Proof)  |  Origin: Greenbrier County, West Virginia, USA  |  Blended American Whiskey  |  Distillery: Smooth Ambler Spirits
Production & Heritage
Smooth Ambler Spirits operates in the mountains of Greenbrier County, West Virginia, a region with limited whiskey-making history that the distillery has worked to put on the map. Old Scout American Whiskey is built from two distinct components, both distilled from classic bourbon mash bills: one is a 9+ year old whiskey with a 36% rye content aged in new charred oak barrels, while the other is a 5+ year old whiskey matured in rejuvenated, re-charred bourbon casks. That second component is the key detail — because the whiskey spent time in previously used barrels rather than exclusively new oak, it cannot legally be labeled bourbon despite its bourbon-style grain recipe. The result is a spirit that drinks like a well-aged bourbon but carries flavors influenced by the seasoned wood character of the rejuvenated barrels, giving it a profile that sits in its own lane within American whiskey.
Tasting Notes
Aroma: Caramel and vanilla arrive immediately, followed by green apple and salted butter. Beneath those sweeter notes, soft tobacco and a distinct rye-driven spiciness emerge as the whiskey opens up.
Taste: The entry is rich with caramel and honeycomb, establishing a full, almost syrupy sweetness on the front palate. At the mid-palate, cinnamon and ginger push through alongside leathery oak tannins and dark fruit. The 99-proof strength carries everything without harshness, allowing a layered interplay between the sweet corn backbone and the rye spice.
Finish: Medium-long, with toffee and dark fruit syrup tapering into dry oak and lingering tobacco. A honey graham sweetness echoes on the tail end, balanced by gentle warmth from the higher proof.
How to Drink Old Scout American Whiskey
At 99 proof, Old Scout rewards neat sipping — the extra strength carries complex flavors without needing dilution, though a few drops of water will open up the green apple and butter notes further. For cocktails, this whiskey punches well above its weight in three classics: an Old Fashioned, where the caramel and tobacco depth pairs naturally with bitters and orange peel; a Boulevardier, where the rye spice and dark fruit hold their own against Campari and sweet vermouth; and a Whiskey Sour, where the honeycomb sweetness and 99-proof backbone create a balanced, full-bodied drink.
Best For
Bourbon drinkers curious about American whiskeys that push beyond traditional classifications
Gifting a whiskey enthusiast who values lesser-known, award-winning distilleries
Building a home bar with versatile, cocktail-ready higher-proof spirits
Side-by-side tastings exploring how barrel type influences flavor in bourbon-mash whiskeys
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Old Scout American Whiskey taste like? Old Scout leads with rich caramel and honeycomb sweetness, then transitions into cinnamon, ginger, leather, and dark fruit, finishing with toffee and soft tobacco. The 99-proof strength adds warmth without burn, making it taste like a well-aged bourbon with extra depth from the rejuvenated barrel component.
How does Old Scout American Whiskey compare to Wild Turkey 101? Both sit near the same proof point and share a bold, spice-forward character, but Old Scout’s use of rejuvenated re-charred barrels introduces a leathery, dark-fruit complexity that Wild Turkey 101’s straightforward new-oak bourbon profile does not emphasize. Old Scout also incorporates a 9+ year old component, giving it more mature wood influence than Wild Turkey 101’s blend of younger and older stocks.
Is Old Scout American Whiskey good for sipping neat? Yes — the 49.5% ABV delivers full flavor without excessive heat, and the blend’s older component adds enough maturity and complexity to reward slow, deliberate sipping without any mixer or dilution.
Where is Old Scout American Whiskey made? Old Scout American Whiskey is produced by Smooth Ambler Spirits, located in Greenbrier County in the mountains of West Virginia. The distillery has earned recognition including a USA Today Readers’ Choice award for Best Craft Whiskey Distillery.
What foods pair well with Old Scout American Whiskey? Smoked brisket or pulled pork complements the whiskey’s tobacco and caramel notes. Dark chocolate with sea salt mirrors the salted butter and toffee character. Sharp aged cheddar stands up to the rye spice. Pecan pie echoes the honeycomb sweetness, and charcuterie with dried fruit aligns with the leather and dark fruit undertones.
What sizes does Old Scout American Whiskey come in? Old Scout American Whiskey is commonly available in the standard 750ml bottle size.
Is Old Scout American Whiskey worth the price? Old Scout positions as a mid-premium American whiskey, and its combination of 9+ year old aged stock, 99-proof bottling strength, and multiple competition medals — including 91 points from the Ultimate Spirits Challenge — delivers strong value relative to similarly aged and proofed expressions from larger producers.
Why Old Scout American Whiskey?
The defining move here is the rejuvenated barrel. By aging one component of the blend in re-charred used bourbon casks rather than new oak, Smooth Ambler created a whiskey that technically cannot be called bourbon but tastes like something more layered and nuanced than most straight bourbons at this price tier. The 91-point score from the 2018 Ultimate Spirits Challenge and Gold and Grand Gold medals at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition confirm that the unusual approach translates to quality in the glass. For drinkers who have explored the major bourbon brands and want something genuinely different — not just different packaging — Old Scout American Whiskey represents a West Virginia distillery making a legitimate case for why American whiskey does not have to mean Kentucky bourbon.