Peerless Toasted Bourbon 750ML

Peerless Toasted Bourbon 750ML is a 109.4-proof (54.7% ABV) sweet mash Kentucky bourbon finished in a medium-toasted oak barrel. It earned 98 points and an Outstanding Gold medal at the 2024 International Wine & Spirit Competition, outscoring bottles from Blanton’s, Four Roses, W.L. Weller, Eagle Rare, and George T. Stagg. A dual-barrel aging approach gives this expression a layered sweetness and spice profile that stands apart from conventional bourbon releases.
Quick Facts: ABV: 54.7% (109.4 Proof)  |  Origin: Louisville, Kentucky, USA  |  5 Years + Toasted Barrel Finish  |  Distillery: Kentucky Peerless Distilling Co.
Production & Heritage
Kentucky Peerless Distilling Co. operates in Louisville, Kentucky, using a strictly sweet mash fermentation process — a more labor-intensive method that starts each batch with fresh yeast rather than recycling spent mash, yielding a cleaner, sweeter distillate. The Toasted Bourbon spends five years maturing in standard char level three American oak barrels before undergoing a secondary maturation in medium-toasted oak barrels. Medium toast was specifically selected because it contains fewer tannins than heavily charred wood, producing a more aromatic whiskey with amplified vanilla, honey, and warm savory characteristics that complement the sweet mash foundation.
Tasting Notes
Aroma: Brown sugar and toasted marshmallow lead immediately, followed by charred oak, honey graham cracker, and warm baking spices. A deeper inhale reveals caramel threads and gentle smoke woven throughout.
Taste: The entry is rich with toffee and caramel, giving way to a full-bodied mid-palate of cinnamon, baked apples, and dark chocolate. At peak intensity, layers of brown sugar and toasted spice emerge alongside pronounced vanilla from the secondary barrel.
Finish: Long and assertively spicy, with lingering oak, leather, and a trace of burnt sugar. The warmth builds gradually without harshness, reflecting the barrel-proof strength and the mellowing influence of the toasted wood.
How to Drink Peerless Toasted
At 109.4 proof, this bourbon rewards a slow pour neat — a few drops of water open up the toasted vanilla and caramel layers without diminishing the barrel-proof intensity. A single large ice cube also tempers the heat while preserving body.
Old Fashioned: The toffee-forward sweetness and toasted spice create a naturally rich Old Fashioned that needs minimal added sugar. Boulevardier: The high proof and chocolate notes stand up to Campari’s bitterness, producing a deeply balanced cocktail. Gold Rush: Honey syrup complements the existing honey and brown sugar character, while lemon brightens the finish.
Best For
Gifting a bourbon collector who appreciates barrel-proof craft releases
Celebrating a milestone with a competition-winning whiskey
Side-by-side tastings comparing char versus toast barrel influence
After-dinner sipping alongside rich chocolate desserts
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Peerless Toasted taste like? Rich toffee, cinnamon, and dark chocolate dominate the palate, supported by baked apple and deep caramel sweetness. The long finish carries oak, leather, and a pleasant burnt sugar note.
How does Peerless Toasted compare to Four Roses Single Barrel? Four Roses Single Barrel at 100 proof emphasizes floral and fruit-forward notes from its high-rye recipes, while Peerless Toasted at 109.4 proof leans into caramelized sweetness and toasted spice from its dual-barrel aging. The toasted barrel finish gives Peerless a richer, more dessert-like profile with greater proof intensity.
Is Peerless Toasted good for sipping neat? The 109.4 proof carries significant warmth, but the toasted barrel finish smooths the edges with sweet vanilla and honey, making it an excellent neat sipper for experienced bourbon drinkers who enjoy barrel-proof intensity.
Where is Peerless Toasted made? Peerless Toasted Bourbon is distilled and aged at Kentucky Peerless Distilling Co. in Louisville, Kentucky, using a sweet mash fermentation process and dual-barrel maturation.
What foods pair well with Peerless Toasted? Dark chocolate truffles mirror the bourbon’s cocoa notes. Pecan pie echoes its brown sugar and toffee sweetness. Smoked brisket complements the oak and leather finish. Blue cheese balances the caramel richness with tangy contrast. Warm apple crisp aligns with the baked apple and cinnamon notes on the palate.
What sizes does Peerless Toasted come in? Peerless Toasted Bourbon is available in the standard 750ml bottle size.
Is Peerless Toasted worth the price? Positioned as a premium craft bourbon, Peerless Toasted justifies its price through barrel-proof bottling, dual-barrel aging, sweet mash production, and exceptional competition credentials including 98 points at the 2024 IWSC and Double Platinum at the 2024 Ascot Awards.
Why Peerless Toasted?
The 98-point Outstanding Gold at the 2024 International Wine & Spirit Competition — where it bested marquee names like George T. Stagg, Blanton’s, and Eagle Rare — places this among the highest-scoring bourbons of recent years. The dual-barrel process, moving spirit from a char level three barrel into a medium-toasted barrel, creates a layered flavor profile that neither a single-barrel char nor a standard finish can replicate. Additional recognition includes Double Platinum at the 2024 Ascot Awards and Double Gold at the 2024 Sip Awards, reinforcing consistency across independent judging panels. For bourbon drinkers seeking barrel-proof intensity with a refined, dessert-like sweetness, this sweet mash expression from Kentucky Peerless occupies genuinely rare territory in the category.